We tested the 3 most popular body butters

We tried the three best-known body butters for men: Ascend Skin, Crowned Skin and Penrose Skin.
What each one smells like, how long the scent lasts, how it feels on your skin, and what it costs. Here is our report.
The facts, side by side
Our pick#1 Ascend Skin

The scent: six scents inspired by luxury colognes, with Zeus (Baccarat Rouge 540), Apollon (Louis Vuitton Imagination) and Helios (Creed Aventus) among them. Infused with pheromones.
Staying power: made to last 12+ hours on your skin.
The feel: a whipped butter made with shea butter, cocoa butter, and coconut, olive and sunflower oils. It absorbs within the minute, so there's no grease on your shirt.
The price: with Buy 2, Get 1 Free, three 5 oz jars come to $56, under $19 a jar. 30-day money-back guarantee, and US delivery estimated at 3 to 6 business days.
Why it's our pick: scents you already know, a 12+ hour claim in writing, and a texture that sinks in.

#2 Crowned Skin

The best known of the three: the brand was featured on Shark Tank.
The scent: five scents, all its own creations. King is mandarin, patchouli, dark vanilla and musk. If you want to smell like a designer cologne you already know, there is no match for it here.
Staying power: Crowned doesn't say how long its scent lasts. The other two both put 12+ hours in writing.
The feel: the formula is all oils, butters and wax, with no water. That makes it a balm, the heaviest kind of moisturizer, and the slowest to sink in.
Why it's second: a rich moisturizer from a known brand, but no designer-inspired scents, no stated staying power, and a smaller jar (4.4 oz) at a higher price.
#3 Penrose Skin

The scent: eleven scents inspired by luxury colognes, with a 12+ hour claim. On paper, the closest to Ascend Skin.
The feel: a cream with water as its first ingredient. Penrose describes it as deep hydration, non-greasy.
The price: $35 for one 5 oz jar, with a 30-day guarantee.
The wait: its shipping policy estimates 5 to 10 business days for delivery, and talks about import duty on US orders.
Why it's third: the same idea as the winner, so it comes down to the scent, the feel and the wait for the jar.

Our pick: Ascend Skin, Buy 2 Get 1 Free
Three jars for the price of two, and you choose the scents.
Try it for a full month. Not convinced? One email, and you get your money back.